Yankee Numbers
Spring 2008 Numbers
Commentary
Retired Numbers
Yankee Classics
Trivia
Yankee Walk-Off HRs
Find All-Stars by Year
Contact Me
Recommended Blogs
Credits
Yes Network
Yankees.com
The Yankee Numbers Poll!
Page will refresh after submitting

To take a different poll, click here
Mystery Photo
Do you know or think you know who this player is?
Click here to help us identify him.
Search for players
and numbers:
Hey, have you ever wondered just how many walk-off home runs the Yankees have had in their history.  I have.  One day I was thinking about how I went to a Yankees/Tigers game sometime in the 80s where the Yankees won on a Dale Berra walk-off home run in the 10th.  At first, I thought it wasn't a particularly special occurrence except for the fact that Dale Berra was the hero that day.  Then I started wondering how rare is it to actually attend a game at Yankee Stadium that ends in a walk-off home run.  So I compiled this list.  Accurate play-by-play records only go back to 1954 so far, but this is a good start.
Date Player Opponent Final WP LP
7/16/1954 Irv Noren Baltimore Orioles 3-2 Whitey Ford Joe Coleman
Situation: 9th inning with 2 outs, the bases empty and the score tied at 2-2.
7/22/1954 Mickey Mantle Chicago White Sox 4-3 Johnny Sain Don Johnson
Situation: 10th inning with 2 outs, the bases empty and the score tied at 3-3.
6/24/1955 Irv Noren Cleveland Indians 2-1 Jim Konstanty Mike Garcia
Situation: 10th inning with 1 out, the bases empty and the score tied at 1-1.
8/2/1955 Joe Collins Cleveland Indians 2-1 Tommy Byrne Early Wynn
Situation: 10th inning with 1 out, the bases empty and the score tied at 1-1.
8/7/1955 Mickey Mantle Detroit Tigers 3-2 Bob Turley Babe Birrer
Situation: 10th inning with 2 outs, the bases empty and the score tied at 2-2.
9/16/1955 Yogi Berra Boston Red Sox 5-4 Jim Konstanty Ellis Kinder
Situation: 9th inning with 2 outs, the bases empty and the score tied at 4-4.
7/1/1956 Mickey Mantle Washington Senators 8-6 Tom Sturdivant Bud Byerly
Situation: 9th inning with 0 out, 1 runner on and the score tied at 6-6.
4/28/1957 Yogi Berra Boston Red Sox 3-2 Don Larsen Ike Delock
Situation: 10th inning with 0 out, the bases empty and the score tied at 2-2.
6/22/1957 Yogi Berra Chicago White Sox 6-5 Tommy Byrne Paul LaPalme
Situation: 13th inning with 0 out, the bases empty and the score tied at 5-5.
9/5/1957 Bob Grim Boston Red Sox 5-2 Bob Grim Willard Nixon
Situation: 9th inning with 2 outs, 2 runners on and the score tied at 2-2.
7/20/1958 Yogi Berra Kansas City Athletics 3-1 Bobby Shantz Ned Garver
Situation: 10th inning with 0 out, 1 runner on and the score tied at 1-1.
8/24/1958 Norm Siebern Detroit Tigers 3-2 Bobby Shantz Herb Moford
Situation: 9th inning with 0 out, the bases empty and the score tied at 2-2.
9/3/1958 Yogi Berra Boston Red Sox 8-5 Ryne Duren Leo Keily
Situation: 9th inning with 1 out, 2 runners on and the score tied at 5-5.
6/18/1959 Mickey Mantle Chicago White Sox 5-4 Bobby Shantz Gerry Staley
Situation: 10th inning with 0 out, the bases empty and the score tied at 4-4.
7/16/1959 Mickey Mantle Cleveland Indians 7-5 Duke Maas Gary Bell
Situation: 10th inning with 2 outs, 1 runner on and the score tied at 5-5.
8/9/1959 Elston Howard Kansas City Athletics 3-2 Bobby Shantz Murry Dickson
Situation: 11th inning with 0 out, the bases empty and the score tied at 2-2.
9/13/1959 Mickey Mantle Cleveland Indians 2-1 Ryne Duren Jack Harshman
Situation: 11th inning with 0 out, 1 runner on and the Yankees trailing 0-1.
5/29/1960 Hector Lopez Washington Senators 6-4 Johnny James Don Lee
Situation: 11th inning with 2 outs, 1 runner on and the score tied at 4-4.
8/2/1960 Bob Cerv Detroit Tigers 3-2 Duke Maas Bob Bruce
Situation: Pinch hitting in the 10th inning with 0 out, the bases empty and the score tied at 2-2.
8/26/1960 Yogi Berra Cleveland Indians 7-6 Luis Arroyo Bobby Locke
Situation: 11th inning with 0 out, the bases empty and the score tied at 6-6.
10/2/1960 Dale Long Boston Red Sox 8-7 Duke Maas Arnold Earley
Situation: 9th inning with 0 out, 1 runner on and the Yankees trailing 6-7.
7/1/1961 Roger Maris Washington Senators 7-6 Jim Coates Dave Sisler
Situation: 9th inning with 0 out, 1 runner on and the Yankees trailing 5-6.
8/4/1961 Johnny Blanchard Minnesota Twins 8-5 Luis Arroyo Bill Pleis
Situation: 10th inning with 2 outs, 2 runners on and the score tied at 5-5.
9/3/1961 Elston Howard Detroit Tigers 8-5 Luis Arroyo Ron Kline
Situation: 9th inning with 1 out, 2 runners on and the score tied at 5-5.
5/22/1962 Mickey Mantle Kansas City Athletics 8-7 Steve Hamilton Bill Fischer
Situation: 11th inning with 0 out, the bases empty and the score tied at 7-7.
5/27/1962 Bill Skowron Detroit Tigers 4-1 Marshall Bridges Doug Gallagher
Situation: 9th inning with 0 out, 2 runners on and the score tied at 1-1.
7/27/1962 Dale Long Chicago White Sox 4-3 Bud Daley Turk Lown
Situation: 12th inning with 2 outs, the bases empty and the score tied at 3-3.
7/31/1962 Tom Tresh Kansas City Athletics 3-2 Ralph Terry Ted Bowsfield
Situation: 9th inning with 2 outs, the bases empty and the score tied at 2-2.
9/29/1962 Tom Tresh Chicago White Sox 8-6 Bob Turley Frank Baumann
Situation: 9th inning with 1 out, 2 runners on and the Yankees trailing 5-6.
9/4/1963 Roger Maris Washington Senators 5-4 Steve Hamilton Claude Osteen
Situation: 9th inning with 0 out, 1 runner on and the Yankees trailing 3-4.
10/10/1964 Mickey Mantle St. Louis Cardinals 2-1 Jim Bouton Barney Schultz
*** World Series - Game 3 *** : Situation: 9th inning with 0 out, the bases empty and the score tied at 1-1.
7/21/1965 Tom Tresh Chicago White Sox 7-6 Steve Hamilton Eddie Fisher
Situation: 10th inning with 1 out, the bases empty and the score tied at 6-6.
7/7/1966 Mickey Mantle Boston Red Sox 5-2 Dooley Womack Don McMahon
Situation: 9th inning with 2 outs, 2 runners on and the score tied at 2-2.
8/26/1966 Mickey Mantle Detroit Tigers 6-5 Hal Reniff Hank Aguirre
Situation: Pinch hitting in the 9th inning with 0 out, 1 runner on and the Yankees trailing 4-5.
4/30/1967 Mickey Mantle California Angels 4-1 Dooley Womack Minnie Rojas
Situation: 10th inning with 1 out, 2 runners on and the score tied at 1-1.
6/24/1967 Mickey Mantle Detroit Tigers 4-3 Dooley Womack Fred Gladding
Situation: 9th inning with 0 out, the bases empty and the score tied at 3-3.
9/1/1967 Mike Hegan Washington Senators 2-1 Fritz Peterson Dick Lines
Situation: 12th inning with 2 outs, the bases empty and the score tied at 1-1.
10/10/1968 Charley Smith Chicago White Sox 2-1 Lindy McDaniel Wilbur Wood
Situation: 9th inning with 2 outs, the bases empty and the score tied at 1-1.
4/17/1969 Joe Pepitone Washington Senators 7-3 Mel Stottlemyre Dennis Higgins
Situation: 10th inning with 2 outs, the bases loaded and the score tied at 3-3.
5/18/1969 Joe Pepitone California Angels 1-0 Steve Hamilton Hoyt Wilhelm
Situation: 9th inning with 0 out, the bases empty and the score tied at 0-0.
8/5/1969 Bobby Murcer California Angels 3-2 Lindy McDaniel Clyde Wright
Situation: 9th inning with 2 outs, 2 runners on and the Yankees trailing 0-2.
8/9/1970 Roy White Baltimore Orioles 6-4 Jack Aker Dick Hall
Situation: 11th inning with 1 out, 1 runner on and the score tied at 4-4.
8/14/1970 Jake Gibbs Kansas City Royals 3-2 Lindy McDaniel Dick Drago
Situation: 10th inning with 0 out, the bases empty and the score tied at 2-2.
9/15/1970 Curt Blefary Boston Red Sox 3-2 Steve Kline Mike Nagy
Situation: Pinch hitting in the 9th inning with 1 out, 2 runners on and the Yankees trailing 0-2.
6/23/1971 Gene Michael Detroit Tigers 6-5 Lindy McDaniel Fred Scherman
Situation: 13th inning with 1 out, the bases empty and the score tied at 5-5.
5/17/1973 Graig Nettles Milwaukee Brewers 4-2 Lindy McDaniel Chris Short
Situation: 11th inning with 1 out, 1 runner on and the score tied at 2-2.
6/24/1973 Graig Nettles Detroit Tigers 2-1 Lindy McDaniel Mickey Lolich
Situation: 9th inning with 1 out, the bases empty and the score tied at 1-1.
8/16/1974 Thurman Munson Chicago White Sox 9-8 Sparky Lyle Terry Forster
Situation: 13th inning with 2 outs, 1 runner on and the Yankees trailing 7-8.
4/30/1975 Bobby Bonds Baltimore Orioles 6-4 Sparky Lyle Bob Reynolds
Situation: 9th inning with 1 out, 2 runners on and the Yankees trailing 3-4.
6/17/1975 Ed Herrmann Milwaukee Brewers 4-2 Dick Tidrow Jim Colborn
Situation: 9th inning with 2 outs, 1 runner on and the score tied at 2-2.
6/6/1976 Oscar Gamble Oakland A's 5-2 Dave Pagan Rollie Fingers
Situation: 9th inning with 2 outs, 2 runners on and the score tied at 2-2.
7/25/1976 Chris Chambliss Boston Red Sox 6-5 Dick Tidrow Tom House
Situation: 9th inning with 2 outs, 2 runners on and the Yankees trailing 3-5.
8/17/1976 Graig Nettles Texas Rangers 2-1 Doyle Alexander Tommy Boggs
Situation: 9th inning with 0 out, the bases empty and the score tied at 1-1.
8/18/1976 Roy White Texas Rangers 8-6 Sparky Lyle Steve Hargan
Situation: 9th inning with 1 out, 1 runner on and the score tied at 6-6.
10/14/1976 Chris Chambliss Kansas City Royals 7-6 Dick Tidrow Mark Littell
*** ALCS - Game 5 *** : Situation: 9th inning with 0 out, the bases empty and the score tied at 6-6.
7/26/1977 Reggie Jackson Baltimore Orioles 5-4 Sparky Lyle Scott McGregor
Situation: 10th inning with 0 out, the bases empty and the score tied at 4-4.
8/16/1977 Chris Chambliss Chicago White Sox 11-10 Ken Clay Randy Wiles
Situation: 9th inning with 1 out, 1 runner on and the Yankees trailing 9-10.
8/30/1977 Mickey Rivers Seattle Mariners 6-5 Sparky Lyle Diego Segui
Situation: 11th inning with 0 out, the bases empty and the score tied at 5-5.
8/31/1977 Graig Nettles Seattle Mariners 5-4 Sparky Lyle Bob Galasso
Situation: 9th inning with 1 out, the bases empty and the score tied at 4-4.
9/14/1977 Reggie Jackson Boston Red Sox 2-0 Ed Figueroa Reggie Cleveland
Situation: 9th inning with 0 out, 1 runner on and the score tied at 0-0.
4/18/1978 Reggie Jackson Baltimore Orioles 4-3 Sparky Lyle Tippy Martinez
Situation: 9th inning with 0 out, the bases empty and the score tied at 3-3.
5/7/1978 Chris Chambliss Texas Rangers 3-2 Rich Gossage Len Barker
Situation: 12th inning with 1 out, the bases empty and the score tied at 2-2.
6/14/1978 Paul Blair Seattle Mariners 11-9 Sparky Lyle Enrique Romo
Situation: 10th inning with 2 outs, 2 runners on and the Yankees trailing 8-9.
6/27/1978 Graig Nettles Boston Red Sox 6-4 Sparky Lyle Dick Drago
Situation: 14th inning with 1 out, 1 runner on and the score tied at 4-4.
7/2/1978 Gary Thomasson Detroit Tigers 5-3 Rich Gossage Jim Slaton
Situation: 9th inning with 2 outs, 1 runner on and the score tied at 3-3.
7/26/1978 Lou Piniella Cleveland Indians 3-1 Rich Gossage Rick Waits
Situation: 9th inning with 1 out, 2 runners on and the Yankees trailing 0-1.
9/2/1979 Oscar Gamble Kansas City Royals 6-5 Rich Gossage Steve Mingori
Situation: 10th inning with 0 out, the bases empty and the score tied at 5-5.
9/27/1979 Oscar Gamble Cleveland Indians 5-2 Rich Gossage Sid Monge
Situation: Pinch hitting in the 9th inning with 2 outs, 2 runners on and the score tied at 2-2.
5/31/1980 Reggie Jackson Toronto Blue Jays 8-6 Rudy May Joey McLaughlin
Situation: 11th inning with 1 out, 1 runner on and the score tied at 6-6.
8/11/1980 Aurelio Rodriguez Chicago White Sox 3-1 Rudy May Britt Burns
Situation: 9th inning with 1 out, 1 runner on and the score tied at 1-1.
8/12/1980 Ruppert Jones Chicago White Sox 8-4 Doug Bird Ed Farmer
Situation: 10th inning with 1 out, the bases loaded and the score tied at 4-4.
6/2/1981 Dave Revering Baltimore Orioles 5-3 Rich Gossage Sammy Stewart
Situation: 11th inning with 1 out, 1 runner on and the score tied at 3-3.
6/3/1981 Graig Nettles Baltimore Orioles 2-0 Ron Davis Tippy Martinez
Situation: 11th inning with 2 outs, 1 runner on and the score tied at 0-0.
9/26/1981 Bobby Murcer Baltimore Orioles 5-3 Ron Davis Tim Stoddard
Situation: Pinch hitting in the 9th inning with 1 out, 2 runners on and the Yankees trailing 3-4.
6/30/1982 Butch Wynegar Baltimore Orioles 4-3 Rich Gossage Tim Stoddard
Situation: 12th inning with 2 outs, the bases empty and the score tied at 3-3.
7/24/1982 Jerry Mumphrey California Angels 6-5 Rudy May Bruce Kison
Situation: 9th inning with 1 out, 1 runner on and the score tied at 5-5.
9/9/1982 Jerry Mumphrey Milwaukee Brewers 5-4 Rudy May Pete Ladd
Situation: 10th inning with 1 out, the bases empty and the score tied at 4-4.
7/20/1983 Don Baylor Minnesota Twins 6-4 Rich Gossage Ron Davis
Situation: 10th inning with 0 out, 1 runner on and the score tied at 4-4.
5/16/1984 Dave Winfield Oakland A's 7-6 Clay Christansen Bill Caudill
Situation: 10th inning with 0 out, 1 runner on and the Yankees trailing 5-6.
9/5/1984 Don Baylor Toronto Blue Jays 4-3 Dave Righetti Roy Lee Jackson
Situation: 10th inning with 2 outs, the bases empty and the score tied at 3-3.
4/16/1985 Don Baylor Chicago White Sox 5-4 Dave Righetti Dan Spillner
Situation: 9th inning with 1 out, the bases empty and the score tied at 4-4.
5/13/1985 Don Mattingly Minnesota Twins 9-8 Joe Cowley Ron Davis
Situation: 9th inning with 2 outs, 2 runners on and the Yankees trailing 6-8.
7/7/1985 Dave Winfield Minnesota Twins 3-2 Dave Righetti Curt Wardle
Situation: 11th inning with 0 out, the bases empty and the score tied at 2-2.
7/1/1986 Dale Berra Detroit Tigers 5-4 Dave Righetti Willie Hernandez
Situation: 10th inning with 1 out, the bases empty and the score tied at 4-4.
8/9/1986 Dan Pasqua Kansas City Royals 3-2 Brian Fisher Bud Black
Situation: 9th inning with 0 out, the bases empty and the score tied at 2-2.
5/8/1987 Mike Pagliarulo Minnesota Twins 11-7 Cecilio Guante Jeff Reardon
Situation: 9th inning with 2 outs, the bases loaded and the score tied at 7-7.
7/31/1987 Gary Ward Detroit Tigers 6-5 Dave Righetti Mike Henneman
Situation: 9th inning with 1 out, 1 runner on and the Yankees trailing 4-5.
9/28/1987 Mike Easler Boston Red Sox 9-7 Bill Fulton Calvin Schiraldi
Situation: Pinch hitting in the 9th inning with 1 out, 1 runner on and the score tied at 7-7.
8/19/1988 Ken Phelps Seattle Mariners 5-3 Dave Righetti Mike Schooler
Situation: 10th inning with 1 out, 1 runner on and the score tied at 3-3.
9/8/1988 Gary Ward Detroit Tigers 7-4 Hipolito Pena Willie Hernandez
Situation: 10th inning with 2 outs, 2 runners on and the score tied at 4-4.
9/9/1988 Claudell Washington Detroit Tigers 3-2 Dale Mohorcic Walt Terrell
Situation: 9th inning with 0 out, the bases empty and the score tied at 2-2.
9/11/1988 Claudell Washington Detroit Tigers 5-4 Steve Shields Willie Hernandez
Situation: 18th inning with 0 out, 1 runner on and the Yankees trailing 3-4.
9/21/1988 Don Slaught Baltimore Orioles 3-2 Dale Mohorcic Mark Thurmond
Situation: 12th inning with 1 out, the bases empty and the score tied at 2-2.
7/14/1989 Jesse Barfield Kansas City Royals 9-7 Lee Guetterman Steve Farr
Situation: 9th inning with 1 out, 2 runners on and the Yankees trailing 6-7.
9/2/1989 Mel Hall California Angels 2-1 Greg Cadaret Mike Witt
Situation: 9th inning with 0 out, the bases empty and the score tied at 1-1.
9/21/1989 Don Mattingly Milwaukee Brewers 5-4 Lee Guetterman Dan Plesac
Situation: 10th inning with 0 out, 1 runner on and the Yankees trailing 3-4.
8/5/1990 Roberto Kelly Cleveland Indians 5-3 Greg Cadaret Steve Olin
Situation: 9th inning with 1 out, 1 runner on and the score tied at 3-3.
5/27/1991 Mel Hall Boston Red Sox 6-5 Lee Guetterman Jeff Reardon
Situation: 9th inning with 0 out, 2 runners on and the Yankees trailing 3-5.
5/31/1991 Jesse Barfield Milwaukee Brewers 3-2 Steve Howe Chuck Crim
Situation: 9th inning with 2 outs, the bases empty and the score tied at 2-2.
8/11/1991 Mel Hall Detroit Tigers 10-8 Steve Farr Paul Gibson
Situation: 10th inning with 1 out, 1 runner on and the score tied at 8-8.
9/18/1991 Roberto Kelly Milwaukee Brewers 2-1 Steve Farr Jaime Navarro
Situation: 10th inning with 0 out, the bases empty and the score tied at 1-1.
6/29/1993 Wade Boggs Detroit Tigers 4-3 Bobby Munoz Tom Bolton
Situation: 10th inning with 0 out, the bases empty and the score tied at 3-3.
10/4/1995 Jim Leyritz Seattle Mariners 7-5 Mariano Rivera Tim Belcher
*** ALDS - Game 2 *** : Situation: 15th inning with 1 out, 1 runner on and the score tied at 5-5.
7/28/1996 Darryl Strawberry Kansas City Royals 3-2 John Wetteland Jason Jacome
Situation: 9th inning with 0 out, 1 runner on and the Yankees trailing 1-2.
10/9/1996 Bernie Williams Baltimore Orioles 5-4 Mariano Rivera Randy Myers
*** ALCS - Game 1 *** : Situation: 11th inning with 0 out, the bases empty and the score tied at 4-4.
5/24/1997 Charlie Hayes Boston Red Sox 4-2 Mariano Rivera John Wasdin
Situation: 9th inning with 1 out, 1 runner on and the score tied at 2-2.
9/21/1997 Tino Martinez Toronto Blue Jays 5-4 Brian Boehringer Carlos Almanzar
Situation: 10th inning with 1 out, 1 runner on and the score tied at 4-4.
8/16/1998 Bernie Williams Texas Rangers 6-5 Mariano Rivera Xavier Hernandez
Situation: 9th inning with 1 out, the bases empty and the score tied at 5-5.
7/3/1999 Scott Brosius Baltimore Orioles 6-5 Jason Grimsley Arthur Rhodes
Situation: 9th inning with 1 out, 2 runners on and the Yankees trailing 3-5.
7/25/1999 Ricky Ledee Cleveland Indians 2-1 Ramiro Mendoza Ricardo Rincon
Situation: 9th inning with 1 out, the bases empty and the score tied at 1-1.
9/24/1999 Alfonso Soriano Tampa Bay Devil Rays 4-3 Mike Stanton Norm Charlton
Situation: 11th inning with 0 out, the bases empty and the score tied at 3-3.
10/13/1999 Bernie Williams Boston Red Sox 4-3 Mariano Rivera Rod Beck
*** ALCS - Game 1 *** : Situation: 10th inning with 0 out, the bases empty and the score tied at 3-3.
10/26/1999 Chad Curtis Atlanta Braves 6-5 Mariano Rivera Mike Remlinger
*** World Series - Game 3 *** : Situation: 10th inning with 0 out, the bases empty and the score tied at 5-5.
5/5/2000 Jorge Posada Baltimore Orioles 12-10 Jeff Nelson B.J. Ryan
Situation: 9th inning with 0 out, 2 runners on and the Yankees trailing 9-10.
8/8/2000 David Justice Oakland A's 3-2 Mariano Rivera Jason Isringhausen
Situation: 9th inning with 0 out, the bases empty and the score tied at 2-2.
4/22/2001 David Justice Boston Red Sox 4-3 Mariano Rivera Derek Lowe
Situation: 10th inning with 2 outs, the bases empty and the score tied at 3-3.
10/21/2001 Alfonso Soriano Seattle Mariners 3-1 Mariano Rivera Kazuhiro Sasaki
*** ALCS - Game 4 *** : Situation: 9th inning with 1 out, 1 runner on and the score tied at 1-1.
10/31/2001 Derek Jeter Arizona Diamondbacks 4-3 Mariano Rivera Byung-Hyun Kim
*** World Series - Game 4 *** : Situation: 10th inning with 2 outs, the bases empty and the score tied at 3-3.
5/17/2002 Jason Giambi Minnesota Twins 13-12 Sterling Hitchcock Mike Trombley
Situation: 14th inning with 1 out, the bases loaded and the Yankees trailing 9-12.
7/17/2003 Hideki Matsui Cleveland Indians 5-4 Mariano Rivera David Riske
Situation: 9th inning with 0 out, the bases empty and the score tied at 4-4.
10/16/2003 Aaron Boone Boston Red Sox 6-5 Mariano Rivera Tim Wakefield
*** ALCS - Game 7 *** : Situation: 11th inning with 0 out, the bases empty and the score tied at 5-5.
7/22/2004 Ruben Sierra Toronto Blue Jays 1-0 Mariano Rivera Vinnie Chulk
Situation: 9th inning with 2 outs, the bases empty and the score tied at 0-0.
8/4/2004 Alex Rodriguez Oakland A's 8-6 Mariano Rivera Justin Duchscherer
Situation: 11th inning with 1 out, 1 runner on and the score tied at 6-6.
9/30/2004 Bernie Williams Minnesota Twins 6-4 Tom Gordon Aaron Fultz
Situation: 9th inning with 1 out, 1 runner on and the score tied at 4-4.
4/5/2005 Derek Jeter Boston Red Sox 4-3 Mariano Rivera Keith Foulke
Situation: 9th inning with 0 out, the bases empty and the score tied at 3-3.
6/15/2005 Jason Giambi Pittsburgh Pirates 7-5 Mariano Rivera Jose Mesa
Situation: 10th inning with 1 out, 1 runner on and the score tied at 5-5.
8/13/2005 Bernie Williams Texas Rangers 7-5 Aaron Small Kameron Loe
Situation: 11th inning with 0 out, 1 runner on and the score tied at 5-5.
9/19/2005 Bubba Crosby Baltimore Orioles 3-2 Mariano Rivera Eric DuBose
Situation: 9th inning with 0 out, the bases empty and the score tied at 2-2.
5/16/2006 Jorge Posada Texas Rangers 14-13 Mariano Rivera Akinori Otsuka
Situation: 9th inning with 2 outs, 1 runner on and the Yankees trailing 12-13.
6/28/2006 Alex Rodriguez Atlanta Braves 4-3 Ron Villone Jorge Sosa
Situation: 12th inning with 1 out, 1 runner on and the Yankees trailing 2-3.
7/18/2006 Melky Cabrera Seattle Mariners 5-4 Scott Proctor Julio Mateo
Situation: 11th inning with 0 out, the bases empty and the score tied at 4-4.
4/7/2007 Alex Rodriguez Baltimore Orioles 10-7 Mariano Rivera Chris Ray
Situation: 9th inning with 2 outs, the bases loaded and the Yankees trailing 6-7.
4/19/2007 Alex Rodriguez Cleveland Indians 8-6 Sean Henn Joe Borowski
Situation: 9th inning with 2 outs, 2 runners on and the Yankees trailing 5-6.
6/5/2008 Jason Giambi Toronto Blue Jays 9-8 Kyle Farnsworth B.J. Ryan
Situation: Pinch hitting in the 9th inning with 2 outs, 1 runner on and the Yankees trailing 7-8.